HomeBlogReviewsCustom engagement rings at your local jeweler

Custom Engagement Rings at your Local Jeweler

by Willyou.net * Jun 2, 2021

Custom Engagement Rings at your Local Jeweler are gratifying to create and definitely worth the cost and wait because of their unique, personal appeal.

Custom Engagement Rings at your Local Jeweler are gratifying to create and definitely worth the cost and wait because of their unique, personal appeal.

When beginning your quest for the perfect diamond engagement ring, get ready for a ton of decisions to make right off the bat. There’s so much out there that it can be hard to separate the wheat from the chaff. The best way to do this is to find your very own, personalized, local jeweler so that they can lead you to quality and away from junk. Your trust in your local diamond jeweler is imperative for a cohesive connection to find her dream ring, and more importantly, to collaborate in the creation of a custom-made engagement ring. 

Custom-made diamond engagement rings are becoming more and more popular. Gone are the days of ‘point and pick’ a ready-made ring at a jewelry store’s window display. Maybe it’s at the hand of our personalized coffee orders or next-day cross-country delivery services that we’ve grown accustomed to getting exactly what we want, when we want it. Either way, custom-designing a ring from scratch is no longer reserved for the likes of the rich and famous. It’s easy, especially once you’re paired with a pre-approved trusted local jeweler.

So where to begin?

How can I get a custom engagement ring?

First, you’ll want to connect with a trusted local diamond jeweler. Make sure you ask around and get personal recommendations, or even better- have someone else do the pre-screening for you. Willyou.net, for example, only works with top local jeweler partners, so you can be sure they’re well-reputed. Your jeweler will walk you through their step-by-step custom designing process so that you can create her dream ring. 

Can I design my own engagement ring?

Of course! You’ll be able to send your local diamond jeweler some visual inspiration, like a joint pinterest board, and give them an idea of what style you’re looking for. You’ll choose a setting, a metal to work with, a diamond, and cut, and together, you’ll design the perfect ring using your jeweler’s diamond expertise. Having a ring custom-made is a way to guarantee that nobody else will have the exact same ring because it will have been personally handcrafted just for her. 

Cost FAQs:

How much does it cost to customize an engagement ring?
How much do people spend on engagement rings?
How much should a man spend on an engagement ring?
How much does a ring setting cost? How much is a diamond for an engagement ring?
How much is a center stone for an engagement ring?

The cost of customizing a diamond engagement ring with your local diamond jeweler can widely vary based on a number of factors. In the past, it was common to go by the “three-month’s-salary” rule but that has long been forgotten. You can find a ring that’s within your budget and refrain from breaking the bank. A trusted local jeweler will gladly work with you and your financial plan to create a beautiful ring without cutting corners.

Your center stone’s carat weight, or size, for one, will greatly affect the price of your ring. If it’s a rarer diamond then, naturally, this will drive up your ring’s price. If you’re working with a diamond already in your possession, say, a family heirloom, then you’re looking at a lower cost. If your diamond is 1-carat, then you’re looking at the $10,000-$15,000 price range. If it’s more intricately set with lots of added detail, again, you’re looking at a greater sum. A larger center stone, accent stones with more carat weight, and more overall intricacy in your setting will take you to the $15,000-$30,000 price range. Using more costly metals like platinum will also increase cost.

How long does it take a jeweler to make a custom ring?

Your timeframe for your custom diamond engagement ring will all depend on your specific local diamond jeweler, their schedule, and store policy. Generally speaking, custom-designing a diamond engagement ring, from start to finish, should take something like 2-4 weeks. Of course, you’re going to want to book your first (of two or three) appointments far in advance of when you’re planning to pop the question. Willyou.net streamlines the custom diamond ring creation process by having you choose a setting and diamond online after having chosen your local diamond jeweler. This means your first appointment with your local jeweler will likely be a crash course in the 4 Cs- carat, clarity, cut, and color, but what’s more is that they’ll already have options for you to look at. Once you go over your exact vision together, you’ll have a second appointment to see the completed ring and make any last changes before picking it up and taking it home!

Can you custom engrave an engagement ring?
How much can you engrave on a ring?

Your local diamond jeweler can make a many number of changes and specifications to your diamond ring, and a personal engraving or inscription is the perfect way to personalize her ring. These types of inscriptions will most commonly be placed on the inside of the shank. 

You could also opt for a decorative vintage feel with engravings on the outside of the ring. Tiny floral, sweeping designs can transform any ring and give it a beautifully detailed aesthetic. Modern designs also use this technique. The small, sharp details on the bridge of the gallery and shank will often be mistaken for small diamonds. 

Machine engraving is achieved when your local jeweler uses a sharp tool that traces a template or pattern of letters and symbols you choose to have inscribed on your ring. The font templates are limited and the engraving isn’t very deep but the overall look is much neater than hand engraving.

Hand engraving, conversely, is imperfect by nature, but has a unique and original charm to it. 

It also allows for more options in terms of style and symbols that the templates simply don’t have. Since engraving by hand is usually deeper set in the ring, the message lasts longer and is more noticeable. The difference in depth from letter to letter or symbol to symbol adds depth and is more visually interesting. 

Laser engraving, while sometimes more expensive, offers more variation in depth, font style, and size. Since the machine is connected to a computer, it’s also much easier to work in other languages. This method is also optimal if you’d like more words to fit on a ring, like a meaningful quote. Certain metals will also require longer dwell times, which can only be achieved by this method. Although it sounds crazy, lasers can even engrave into the girdle of a diamond. It will only be seen under high magnification but wow. What a lovely secret surprise.

Can you engrave a ring after it’s made?

The nice thing about inscriptions is that you can get them done whenever you want. Your local diamond jeweler can work with you to have the ring engraved and ready for your proposal, or, you can get something added years later. Some people like to surprise their spouse years later, while getting the ring “cleaned”, with a loving and meaningful message. It’s up to you whether or not you tell her, or let her discover it on her own…

What should I get engraved on an engagement ring?

The possibilities are endless! Some people have the words “I Promise” engraved either on the inside of the shank or have a split engraving with “I Promise” on the outside and “to love you” or “to cherish you” continued on the inside. Other popular words or phrases include the obvious, “I love you” or a simple and powerful “Forever” or “Eternity.” Other commonly requested phrases like “Soul Mates”, “To have and to hold”, and “My heart is yours to keep” are always a sure bet. 

You won’t go wrong with lines from romantic poetry or Shakespeare like: 

  • ‘If music be the food of love, play on’
  • ‘Who ever loved that loved not at first sight?’
  • ‘I would not wish any companion in the world but you’
  • ‘I humbly do beseech of your pardon, For too much loving you’
  • ‘My bounty is as boundless as the sea’
  • ‘The more I give to thee, the more I have’

You could have something engraved in your or their mother tongue, or simply in one of the romance languages like: 


Joie sans fin (Joy without end) 

Pour tous jours (For all days) 

Mon coeur est a vous (My heart is yours)


Il mio cuore è tuo per sempre (My heart is yours forever)


Te adoro (I adore you)

Eres el amor de mi vida (You are the love of my life)

Te quiero con todo mi corazón (I love you with all of my heart)

Or even in Latin:

Semper amemus (Let us always love) 

Amor vincit omnia (Love conquers all)

If you or your spouse is Jewish, you might want to go with the well-known “I am my Beloved’s and my Beloved is mine” written in beautiful Hebrew letters. Actually, if they speak another language or if they have an ancestral language that they feel connected to, do some research and find the perfect fit.

If you have nicknames for each-other that might be a cute idea to consider. Perhaps a word, name, or phrase referencing a shared experience or how you first met. Personalizing your engraving with an important date or meaningful location coordinates is a fantastic idea. 

Also, an original idea that we’ve seen growing in popularity over the last few years is getting a famous movie quote engraved on your ring. Getting “I love you” on one band and “I know” on the other, referencing the iconic Han Solo and Princess Leia exchange is a fan fave. 

Here are some others: 

“The greatest thing you’ll ever learn is just to love, and be loved in return.” 

  • Christian, Moulin Rouge (2001)

“I would rather share one lifetime with you than face all the ages of this world alone.” 

  • Arwen, Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001) 

“I want all of you, forever, you and me, every day.” 

  • Noah, The Notebook (2004)

“You should be kissed and often, and by someone who knows how.” 

  • Rhett Butler, Gone With the Wind (1939)

And of course:

“As you wish…” 

  • Westley, The Princess Bride (1987)

How long does it take to get a ring engraved?

Any in-store engraving at your local diamond jeweler shouldn’t take longer than a day or day. If you’re having your diamond engagement ring laser-engraved, it could take up to two weeks.

Bottom Line:

Custom engagement rings at your local jeweler are a perfect way to personalize your diamond ring. Proposing with any diamond ring will, of course, be sufficient, but custom designing and creating a ring made specifically for her by you (with the help of your trusted local diamond jeweler) will undoubtedly knock her socks off. Begin planning your custom-made engagement ring today by heading to Willyou.net and finding the local jeweler nearest you. https://willyou.net/jewelry-stores