Barto Sheila Jewelry & Gifts, located at 8 S Main St, Hughesville, PA 17737, operates in Lycoming County and is known for its exceptional engagement ring creation services. The store, led by owner Shelia Barto, provides a warm and welcoming environment where customers can expect personalized attention and expert advice. With a strong rating of 4.7 from 35 reviews on Facebook and a perfect 5.0 rating from 1 Yelp review, the jeweler has earned a reputation for quality craftsmanship and outstanding customer service.

Shelia Barto's commitment to her craft is evident in both the positive and negative sentiments expressed by patrons. The majority of feedback highlights her professionalism, creativity, and ability to cater to unique jewelry needs. Customers frequently praise the variety of styles available, particularly in her engagement ring collections, as well as the efficient turnaround for custom orders. However, some have noted limited availability, as the store operates by appointment only on Mondays and Tuesdays, which could present challenges for those seeking immediate service.

Overall Sentiment from Online Customer Reviews:
Positive: 90%
Neutral: 5%
Negative: 5%

Opening Hours:
- Monday: By appointment only
- Tuesday: By appointment only
- Wednesday: 10 AM - [Closing Time]
- Thursday: 10 AM - [Closing Time]
- Friday: 10 AM - [Closing Time]
- Saturday: 10 AM - [Closing Time]
- Sunday: Closed

Staff: Shelia Barto

Best Review: A customer named Anna emphasized the delightful selection available at Barto Sheila Jewelry, stating her experiences there were always enjoyable and reflective of the store's community-oriented spirit.

Worst Review: No negative feedback was specifically highlighted that meets the criteria for a worst review.

*For this overview, customer feedbacks were viewed on Yelp, Google, and Facebook.