Garco Jewelry, located at 334 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791, is a notable destination for those seeking exquisite engagement rings and exceptional jewelry services. The store has garnered a strong reputation over the years, with a total of 55 reviews, showcasing both the craftsmanship and customer service provided by the staff. With an impressive rating of 4.8, Garco Jewelry is highly regarded for its unique designs and attention to detail in engagement ring creation.

Customers frequently commend the owners, Gary and Sophy, for their honesty, creativity, and personalized service. Many reviews highlight the beautiful, original designs featuring semi-precious stones set in gold and diamonds. The store is praised for its warm atmosphere, making every visit a pleasant experience. Positive comments specifically mention the knowledgeable staff who take the time to ensure customers find exactly what they desire, alongside a commitment to quality workmanship.

However, some reviews also note that prices for repairs and resizing may be higher than typical, which could be a consideration for those on a tight budget. Additionally, there are mentions of some negative experiences regarding pricing discrepancies and service expectations, but these are outweighed by the numerous positive testimonials.

Overall Sentiment from Online Customer Reviews:
Positive: 90%
Neutral: 5%
Negative: 5%

**Opening Hours:**
- Monday to Friday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Saturday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed

**Staff Members:**
- Gary
- Sophy

Best Review:
A customer named Judy expressed her long-standing loyalty to Garco Jewelry, praising Gary's skills as a jeweler and noting the beautiful, tasteful jewelry offerings that make each visit enjoyable.

Worst Review:
Aviva mentioned that while Garco Jewelry boasts original jewels, she found their pricing for repairs and resizing to be quite high compared to other options in the area.

*For this overview, customer feedbacks were viewed on Yelp, Google, and Facebook.