McCall Jewelry Company, located at 207 E Lake St, McCall, ID, is a charming destination for anyone looking to create a memorable engagement ring. This locally-owned store, run by the husband and wife team Erica and George Seeds, has become a beloved fixture in the community since its founding in 2008. They offer a full range of services, including custom designs, which allow customers to create one-of-a-kind pieces using a diverse selection of Idaho gemstones and fine materials.

Customers appreciate the warm, family-like atmosphere as they browse through an impressive array of jewelry. The expert staff is frequently praised for their friendly service and in-depth knowledge, making the ring creation process not only enjoyable but also personal. Many clients find that the team's attention to detail and willingness to listen to their desires translate into stunning, meaningful pieces that perfectly encapsulate their love stories. Despite the overwhelmingly positive experiences, a small percentage of reviews indicate difficulties with pricing transparency and occasional delays in communication.

Customer Sentiment: Approximately 80% of customers are highly satisfied, while 10% have expressed neutral feelings and 10% have encountered issues.

Opening Hours:

Tuesday to Saturday: 10:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Sunday & Monday: Closed

Best Review: Faith praised the beautiful jewelry and exceptional customer service, noting that George and Erica make customers feel like family every time they visit.

Worst Review: Sage expressed disappointment regarding service, feeling that there was a lack of transparency over pricing, particularly when inquiring about specific chains.

This overview is based on customer feedback gathered from Yelp, Google, and Facebook.