McIntyre Jewelry, located at 715 E 8th St, Ste 2, Anderson, IN 46012, operates in Madison County and specializes in engagement ring creation and related services. The store offers a friendly, family-owned atmosphere with knowledgeable staff ready to assist customers in selecting or crafting the perfect engagement ring.

The service is highly regarded, with many customers praising the attentive and helpful staff. Reviews indicate that the store provides a seamless experience for both ring resizing and repair services, often completing tasks quickly and efficiently. The shop has also been noted for its reasonable prices and quality workmanship.

However, some reviews reveal consistency issues, particularly regarding the care taken during repairs, with reports of missing stones upon pickup. Customers have expressed concerns regarding pricing, indicating that quotes for certain services may be higher than competitor rates.

Overall Sentiment from Online Customer Reviews:
Positive 82%, Neutral 12%, Negative 6%

Highlight Reviews:
Best Review: Nancy appreciated the excellent service and reasonable prices at McIntyre Jewelry, highlighting the friendliness of the staff in a family-owned environment.
Worst Review: Olivia expressed disappointment after picking up her resized ring only to find a missing diamond, questioning the trustworthiness of the service following an expensive quote for an appraisal.

Operating Hours:
- Tuesday: 9 am–5 pm
- Wednesday: 9 am–5 pm
- Thursday: 9 am–5 pm
- Friday: 9 am–5 pm
- Saturday: Closed
- Sunday: Closed
- Monday: 9 am–5 pm

Staff members include David McIntyre, who is recognized for his expertise and commitment to customer satisfaction.

* For this overview, customer feedbacks were viewed on Yelp, Google, and Facebook.