Gaertner's Jewelers Supply, located at 2238 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL, has gained attention in the local jewelry scene, particularly for its engagement ring creation and related services. Despite mixed reviews, this establishment is known for its committed service and family-operated charm.

Customers appreciate the often friendly and knowledgeable staff, though experiences vary. The store has been recognized for its solid reputation and the extensive experience of its team, who are willing to assist with various jewelry needs. However, some customer feedback points to issues with service consistency, particularly regarding sizing and repair services, which seem to paint a more complicated picture of the customer experience.

Customer Sentiment: Approximately 70% of customers are satisfied with their experiences, while 15% have reported neutral feelings, and 15% have faced challenges.

Opening Hours:
Monday to Friday: N/A
Saturday: N/A
Sunday: Closed

Best Review: Eugenio praised Gaertner's for its extensive knowledge and family-oriented service, feeling confident in their expertise.

Worst Review: Stevie expressed disappointment with the customer service, highlighting a negative experience with jewelry repair that left him frustrated.

This overview is based on customer feedback gathered from Yelp, Google, and Facebook.