We're sorry but willyou doesn't work properly without JavaScript enabled. Please enable it to continue.
SHOP ENGAGEMENT RINGS WITH JEWELER AI
Jeweler AI by Willyou.com – an independent tool to effortlessly help you find the perfect diamond engagement ring. No ties to the listed jewelers.
START NOW!
Jeweler AI by Willyou.com – an independent tool to effortlessly help you find the perfect diamond engagement ring. No ties to the listed jewelers.
Ad
Jewelry stores near you
Store Locator
BLOG
ABOUT
Store Locator
BLOG
ABOUT
Home
・
Store Locator
・
NY
・
Bay Shore
Last Updated May 2025
BEST 11 Jewelers & Jewelry Stores in Bay Shore, NY
NY
Kay Jewelers Westfield South Shore
Bay Shore , NY
90%
Positivity Score
Positivity Score:
90%
View Jeweler
NY
Kristins Fine Jewelry
Bay Shore , NY
70%
Positivity Score
Positivity Score:
70%
View Jeweler
NY
Zales Jewelers - South Shore Mall
Bay Shore , NY
52.5%
Positivity Score
Positivity Score:
52.5%
View Jeweler
Design Your Ring with Jeweler AI
Jeweler AI by Willyou.com – an independent tool to effortlessly help you find the perfect diamond engagement ring. No ties to the listed jewelers.
The smart, stress-free path to creating an engagement ring that’s uniquely yours
START NOW
Ad
All Jewelry Stores in Bay Shore, NY
1
Kristins Fine Jewelry,Ltd.
2
Zales
3
Kay Jewelers
10 Leading Jewelry Stores for Engagement Rings Across the USA
Tiffany & Co
1
Tiffany & Co
Zales
2
Zales
Jared
3
Jared
Kay Jewelers
4
Kay Jewelers
Helzberg Diamonds
5
Helzberg Diamonds
Brilliant Earth
6
Brilliant Earth
Reeds Jewelers
7
Reeds Jewelers
Robbins Brothers
8
Robbins Brothers
Blue Nile
9
Blue Nile
James Allen
10
James Allen
Best Places to Propose in Bay Shore, NY
1
Boulton Center for the Performing Arts
2
Drew Patrick Spa